






| |     
History 1820 British Settler: Captain Thomas Butler Born in 1776 in the town of Baltinglass in Wicklow (County), Ireland. |
| He attained the rank of "Captain" in the Dublin (County) Militia, in 1807. Circa 1800, and married Elizabeth, (born in 1785), in Baltinglass. |
Capt.Thos. BUTLER aged 43 years, his wife Elizabeth 35 years. Eldest son John 19 years, second son Joseph 11 years, third son James aged 6 years and only daughter Matilda aged one year. |
| The following relevant extracts from “Happy Families” kindly supplied by John Butler of the Butler Society: Happy Families"HAPPY FAMILIES" is a serial of continuing research into the genealogy of families named BUTLER, compiled by Lord Dunboyne, and published in the Journal of the Butler Society. This table lists the 456 queries and subsequent follow-ups published in Butler Journals Vol.1#1 (1968) to Vol.4#1 (1997). Q417. BJ3#4 Thomas Butler (b, c. 1777), Capt., Dublin Militia; emigrated to S. Africa, 1820. QUOTE: Q417. BJ3#4 Thomas Butler (b, c. 1777), Capt., Dublin Militia; emigrated to S. Africa, 1820. Clue: With wife, Elizabeth (33) and children, Joseph (11), James (6) and Matilda (1 year), he led a party of 27 settlers from Co. Wicklow who eventually settled in the Zuurveld (later known as Albany), near Algoa Bay. In the same group was John Butler, aged 19 (per James's descendant, Mrs Simpson of Despatch, S. Africa, via Major R. E. Butler of California). Reply: Thomas Butler became Capt. in Dublin (County) Militia, 1807 (List of Militia Officers, PRO, Kew); |
| 
The adventure begins when he puts pen to paper: From Whitehall House in village of Baltinglass in Co. Wicklow, Capt. Butler then forwarded his letter of application on 10 September 1819... |
BUTLER, Thomas Baltinglass, 18th Sept 1819 My Lord I have the honour of enclosing for you Mr. GRANT’s recommendation of me as a fit and proper person to become (with ten families) a Settler in Africa. I have been strongly recommended to Mr. GRANT by some of the most respectable men in this Island who have known me for twenty years. My claims are also something as I lost nearly 20 yrs of my life as a Subaltern and Capt. of Militia during all the Disturbances here and am now without any provision whatever except my own property – The Heads of the Ten Families who have agreed to come with me are mostly men who have been in the service and are like myself trained to arms as well as to labour. I have the hundred pounds ready to send wherever you direct and am perfectly willing to comply with the prescribed regulations (sent to me by Mr. GRANT) in every particular. The most expensive part of this undertaking will be conveying the people to the place of embarkation, and on that account I will thank you to let me know whether the fleet will touch at any which of our sea ports, when it will sail, and as provisions seem from the last accounts I see from the Cape to be scarce whether I will be allowed to bring out a reasonable quantity of what I think might be serviceable as I will support them all untill the crops are sown our arrival comes round – From the printed pages? I see the Government have reserved to themselves ? of selecting the most eligible of the officers, but my being eligible trusts my claim, as I will have much to do between this and the time of embarkation. I beg the favour of a speedy answer. And have the honour to be My Lord Your most ob’t humble servt Thos. BUTLER I would not emigrate to any place where I had not the protection of the British laws. I have always supported them and will do so as long as I breathe. |
Dublin, Sept 15 1819 My dear GOULBURN, You will be annoyed by my frequent letters. But I beg, thro’ you, to present to Lord BATHURST Captain BUTLER, who is desirous to settle at the Cape, with some number of families. I have only to state that, upon the authority of very respectable persons, I am induced to believe him in every respect fitted for the employment, and of excellent character. Always my dear GOULBURN yours truly C. GRANT |
Baltinglass 30 September 1819 My Lord, On the 17th inst I had the honour of addressing you in respect to my wish to proceed and being ten families with me to the new settlements being established in Africa. I also enclosed your Lordship in that letter Mr. GRANT’s (the Lord Lieutenant’s secretary) recommendation as being an eligible person for that undertaking. I have most anxiously awaited an answer to this letter to which I refer you, should the fleet sail in November I have but a short time to prepare & I have a good deal to dispose of. I have the L100 ready to lodge. The ten families are ready and I am willing to comply in every respect with the wish of government. Should you require any further recommendation of me I can procure the very best in this Island. Intreat your answer as soon as possible as my anxiety is very great. Have the honour your most obdt sevt Thos. BUTLER |
Baltinglass, 10th October 1819 Sir, Agreeable to your instructions I enclose you the three lists filled up. The men are all fit for service and their families small. I have given at foot an account of my own family which least I should not insert properly I leave for you to fill up. I have had as Male and Female servants for many years who wish to accompany me. I suppose they will be included in my own Family. I have the honour to be Yr most ob’t sevt. Thos. BUTLER |
Baltinglass 29th October 1819 Sir, According to your directions in your last letter I have directed my friend Mr. Joseph LAPHAM of Cork Street, Dublin to forward to the Treasury in London one hundred and twenty two pounds ten shillings being the amount of my deposit for bringing out ten families to the new settlements in Africa. As I have some things yet to dispose of and other arrangements to make you will serve me materially by letting me know when tis probable the fleet will sail and if it is at Cork my party and myself will be picked up. I have the honour to be most obediently yours Thos. BUTLER |
Baltinglass, 21st November 1819 Sir Yesterday I had the honour of receiving yours of the 15th inst containing all the necessary papers and instructions, to those of which are very explicit I shall most carefully attend – you will excessively oblige me and serve me materially by letting me know when you think the fleet will sail and at what port here we will be taken up. I have two very strong reasons for wishing to get this information. The first is that I might forward my baggage which will require many necessary going to settle where there is nothing and I wish to bring out seeds of different kinds as well as implements. Secondly both myself and those who have placed themselves under my directions will require to regulate affairs in respect to provisions as long as we might remain here. Indeed some of them are without any support except in my house, more buying, others besides myself having some things to dispose of – Will you also have the goodness to let me know whether I will be allowed for my own family more than the ship allowance. Most obediently yours, Thos. BUTLER |
BYRNE, Edward Rathwilly Near Baltinglass 23rd October 1819 The petition of Edward BYRNE of Rathwilly in the County Carlow, Land Surveyor, most humbly sheweth That petitioner served in His Majesty’s navy ten years, fought in the memorable Battle of Trafalgar under Sir Richard KING Bart in His Majesty’s ship Achilles and who at the capture of four French frigates off Rockford on board said ship was in the expedition to Flushing and at the conclusion of the peace after receiving a serious contusion in actual service was discharged with the small annuity of four pounds p.a. That petitioner is well practised in surveying and dividing of land, can teach the principle rules of arithmetic and geometry, can procure if required certificates from any neighbouring gentlemen, would willingly embark for the Cape of Good Hope with his family consisting of a wife and four children if your Lordship would approve thereof as he flatters himself they would make useful members of society and might be of use in an infant colony, all which he most humbly submits to the consideration of your Lordship. What induced petitioner to this resolve is that several gentlemen of this neighbourhood, chiefly a Mr. BUTLER and Mr. BURGESS are preparing to embark for said colony, I suppose under the auspices of your Lordship. Petitioner waits your Lordship’s reply most humbly, hoping your Lordship will be graciously pleased to return a favourable answer. Your petitioner with all due respect most humbly subscribes himself your Lordship’s most obedient humble servant Edward BYRNE |
|
Article Extracts 1820 British SettlersSome 60 parties of English, Scots and Irish immigrant families disembarked on the desolate shore of Algoa Bay, then on the eastern border of the Cape Colony, in 1820.
Lord Charles Somerset, the strong willed governor of the Cape, became convinced that only large-scale immigration - from Britain, since 'anglicization' was a part of official policy - could bring peace, or at the worst an armed neutrality, to the troubled border regions. These immigrants would farm the Zuurveld (named the Albany district in 1814) and provide a buffer between the Xhosa and the more settled White areas to the west. Of the 90 000 applicants, 4 000 were selected. The first shipload landed on 10 April.
Upon arrival in Algoa Bay, there were already a dozen large vessels anchored there. Ashore was a small-fortified barracks (Fort Frederick) occupied by a detachment of the 72nd Regiment and surrounded by tents and marquees in which the officers were billeted. The only signs of permanency were three thatched cottages and wooded houses, used as offices for the commissaries and officials involved in the immigration scheme. Here and there along the beach were large depots of farming implements, carpenters and blacksmith's tools and ironware. These settlers would be able to buy at a modest price.
Communications in those days were slow and faulty, and the authorities in Cape Town could only guess at the number of immigrants to expect. The camp (sited at the junction of what was to become Port Elizabeth's Russell Road and Main Street) was able to accommodate 1 500, but there were rations to feed only 2 000 people for a single month. Farmers in the Uitenhage and Graaf-Reinet districts had been persuaded to lend wagons, oxen and drivers to take the new arrivals to their allocated lands.
At first, all the wagons took the same route into the interior: along the coast across the Zwartkops and Koega Rivers, then north-east over the Sundays River, the Addo Heights and the Quagga Flats, and through Rautenbachs Drift on the Bushmans River, the western boundary of the colony. Assegai Bush was the parting of the ways for those in the procession. The nearest plots were 100km away: the farthest an intimidating 200km. Some of the parties had to lumber along the rugged track for almost a fortnight before they arrived at their destinations.
Those families who were to settle near the Great Fish River had, until now, been in blissful ignorance of the government's true intention in bringing them there. Warning bells sounded clear, however, when they took leave of Jacob Cuyler, landrost of Uitenhage who had accompanied them thus far. "Gentlemen" he said, "when you go out and plough never leave your guns at home." It dawned on the newcomer that they were to serve not as farmer but also as a kind of plain-clothes militia. In fact, a small contingent of troops had been stationed on the west bank, but the settlers fears were prove only to well founded.
Two poignant reminiscences show clearly their feelings of disappointment and loss. An anonymous settler, who was a child in 1820, wrote "I remember that while the wagons were being unloaded, prompted y curiosity, I ran down to the small river that was near, an on my return found my mother sitting on a large box and crying. On asking her what was the matter, she said she was afraid, she thought tigers and wolves would come through that night and eat us up."
Later, during that first, harsh season, a Captain Thomas Butler penned a letter describing his desolation. "My wheat" he wrote, "two months ago the most promising I ever saw in any country, is now cut down in heaps for burning... The rust has utterly destroyed it: not a grain have we saved. My barley, from the drought, and a grub, which attacks the blade, produced little more than I sowed. My Indian corn, very much injured by the caterpillar; cabbages destroyed by lice: the beans all scorched by the hot wind... Our cows are all dry from want of grass: not the least appearance of verdure as far as the eye can reach. Nothing but one great wilderness of faded grass. On Saturday whilst watching by the sick bed of my dear little girl- she had been bitten by a snake while running over the veld without shoes and stockings, and died. I was startled by the cry of wild dogs. I ran to the window and saw about thirty of these ferocious animals: before I could drive them off, they had killed twenty of my flock, which consisted of twenty-seven in all. I stood for a minute thinking of my misery, my dying child, my blasted crops, and my scattered and ruined flock. God's will be done. I have need of fortitude to bear up against such accumulation of misery."
For five years the settlers suffered bitter hardship. Many of them had no experience of farming: their allotments were too small: their implements rudimentary. There were locusts and droughts, the depredations of the Xhosa- and a ban on the recruitment of black labour. Most of them surrendered their struggle with the unforgiving land and drifted into the small settlements, many of which, like Grahamstown., had started as military garrisons.
But the scheme, in terms of the government's plans, was not an entire failure. The settlers added more than 10% to the total white population, and they indeed help create Somerset's buffer zone. And after 1925, matters improved with the establishment of bigger farming units, a relaxation of government restrictions and, above all, with the launching of what were to become a flourishing sheep industry. |
|
| In 1820, 2 ships arrived from Cork with about 350 Irish. They were first settled in Clanwilliam, but most of them eventually joined the other British settlers in Albany (Eastern Province).   |
|
|
Ship | Fanny | Scheme | the Government Settler Scheme | Tonnage | c 400 | Departure Port | Cork | Parties | Butler, Ingram, Synnot | Number on Board | 112 | Departure Date | 12th February 1820 | Landfall Port | Simon's Bay | Landfall Date | 1st May 1820 | Final Port | Saldhana Bay |
1820 Settler: Thomas Butler Settler ID | 1149 | Ship | Fanny | Party | Butler | Gender | M | Age in 1820 | 43 | Occupation | Capt, Dublin Militia | Date or Year of Birth | 1776 | Spouse | Elizabeth |
Party | Butler | Leader | Capt. Thomas Butler | Number in the Party | 27 | Area Party originated from | Wicklow, Ireland | Area allocated to the party | Originally to Clanwilliam, then to the Assegai Bush River, Alban | Ship | Fanny | Surnames in party | Butler, Byrne, Devine, Dougherty, Fowler, Goss, Harrington, Healey, Mageer, Montgomery, Mulhall, Murray, Sadler, Toole, Unknown, Walsh, Whelan, | Notes | A party of 27 from Wicklow led by Captain Thomas BUTLER, Dublin Militia, sailed in "Fanny". They were located in Jan Dissels Valley, Western Cape. Most of them were shortly transferred to "East Indian", for re-location on the Assegai Bush River. |
Thomas Butler's Family: Last Name, Given Name(s) | Ship | Party | Parents | Born/Christened | Spouse | Person ID | | | | | | | | | Butler, Thomas | Fanny | Butler | | b. 1776 | | Elizabeth | 1149 | Butler, John | Fanny | Butler | Thomas Butler and Elizabeth | b. 1800 | | | 1179 | Butler, Joseph | Fanny | Butler | Thomas Butler and Elizabeth | b. 1809 | | | 1150 | Butler, James | Fanny | Butler | Thomas Butler and Elizabeth | b. 1813 | | | 1151 | Butler, Matilda | Fanny | Butler | Thomas Butler and Elizabeth | b. 1818 | | | 1152 |
The list below contains details of the members of the above party which formed part of the British government-assisted emigration scheme to the Cape Colony, South Africa.
The settler's age in 1820 in years is reflected in brackets. Where no age is given it is either unknown or less than one year in the case of children. Surname | Name | Spouse, if applicable | Children, if applicable | Occupation/ Other | | Butler | Thomas (43) | Elizabeth (35) | Joseph (11) James (6) Matilda (1) | Captain, Dublin Militia | | Byrne | Murtagh (33) | Jane (30) | Patrick (13) William (7) | Labourer | | Devine | James (36) | Margaret (26) | William (11) Ellen (4) | Labourer | | Fowler | Thomas (36) | | | Carpenter | | Goss | Michael (21) | | | Labourer | | Harrington | James (22) | Frances (20) | | Labourer | | Healey | John (21) | | | Labourer | | Mageer | William (36) | | Thomas (8) | Labourer | | Montgomery | John (16) | | | Listed as 'John Fowler' | | Murray | Edward (21) | Jane (19) | *a daughter | Labourer | | Toole | Michael (21) | Honora (20) | | Labourer | | Walsh | Laurence (40) | | Elizabeth (8) James (7) | Labourer | | Whelan | John (21) | | | Labourer |
A birth entry found in the archives indicates that there may have been another son born at a later stage named "George". This is instalment #06 of the Anglican Church Records for Grahamstown, Eastern Cape, South Africa. This church was later named St. George's Anglican Cathedral, but that was not until 1838 and still later it was dedicated as St. Michael and St. George's Anglican Cathedral. These records are taken from the original register which is kept at the Cory Library, Grahamstown. In those early days all the churches used the same church building!
The writing in these registers is fairly good but in some instances it is difficult to read and a ? will be displayed where I couldn't read the name in full. If you have a correction please send it to me so that the file can be updated. It would appear that neither of these ministers was very good with the spelling of names!! Please ensure that you check everything for yourself. I have typed the names exactly as spelt in the register.
Anglican Church Register, Grahamstown Baptisms: 1820-1826 Cory Reference: CORY MS 14 877/1 Entry 174 Surname: BUTTLER -> BUTLER Christian Names: George Parents Names: Thomas and Elizabeth Abode: Nerville? -> Melville Occupation: Late Captain in the Dublin County Militia DOB: 03 Aug 1824 Date Baptised: 24 April 1825 Minister: Rev Thomas Ireland - Chaplain 
|
Note-1: There was Joseph, James (on who's head a tent pole fell causing an injury to his brain), mention of John and also of a Robin? Elizabeth (first wife) went back to Ireland after the trauma of Matilda dying from snake bite and then suffering an ear infection from sleeping on damp ground resulting in deafness - what happened to her? Thomas' daughter from 2nd marriage, Elizabeth, married Francis Holder (William Holder son) (arrived in SA same year from Bristol on the 'Kennerley Castle'.) He must have married again, because it sounds as if the daughter Elizabeth (that married Francis Holder) was born after mother Elizabeth returned??? Note-2: Matilda may buried on Melville Park, which was apparently the farm he lived on in the Cape. On 05/11/1826 Thomas sold it to John (Hancorn) Smith. Note-3: Although we know that Elizabeth returned to Ireland, she might have gone back to SA later, and still be the mother of the Elizabeth that married Francis Holder. We found something written by Montgomerie (a young man that stowed away on the ship)...he bumped into Thomas Butler years later in a town somewhere, and said the poor man was in such a bad state. Africa must have been such a harsh place in those days! Montgomerie said he barely had shoes on his feet, but said that things will get better, because Elizabeth has gone back to Ireland to send him money. So whether she returned or not is a bit of a mystery??? It must have been very hard for Thomas, as he was very much upper class in Ireland. Note-4: It seems that he (Thomas) personally paid £100 to get these 10 families to the ship, a long journey apparently. It must have been a fortune in those days. Where did he get it from? Also, he talks about his own property. As is most probably known, in those days very, very few people owned their own properties....so was it a family property etc?? Lots of questions! The families had to pay to go to SA. It was £10 per person or £10 for a man, his wife and 2 children under 14. £5 per child for older children. Quite a lot really! It is noted that farmers earned about £120 per year, artisans around £55 and farm labourers around £30 per year!! |
Extracts from articles paint a formidable picture: The next immigration scheme was the 1820 Settlers, which brought out approx. 4500 settlers. They arrived on board 21 ships, the first being the Chapman:, arrived in Algoa Bay on 09 April 1820. Among the settlers were artisans, tradesmen, ministers of religion, merchants, teachers, bookbinders, blacksmiths, discharged sailors and soldiers, professional men and farmers. They were settled in British Kaffraria, where their first homes were the tents given to them by the government. They pitched their tents once they had chosen their piece of land. Their first task was to build a more permanent abode for their families, after which they started to till the lands. The government wanted them as farmers, but many settlers did not have farming experience. Soon the drift towards towns started and this is where these settlers started making their mark on South African society. They started a free press, schools, churches, and businesses. Those who had stayed on the farms eventually began to prosper. |
|
| | | | |
|